After evaluating a manuscript, reviewers are required to complete the Journal’s official Review Form (Evaluation Sheet). This form is designed to guide a structured and consistent assessment of the manuscript and support the editorial decision-making process.
General Instructions
- Carefully read and assess the full manuscript before completing the form
- Provide clear, constructive, and objective feedback based on the manuscript content
- Ensure your responses are professional, evidence-based, and focused on improving the quality of the work
- Maintain confidentiality throughout the review process
Completing the Review Form
The Review Form contains sections that guide your evaluation of different aspects of the manuscript. Reviewers are expected to:
- Provide comments for each evaluation area based on the manuscript’s strengths and weaknesses
- Assess key aspects such as originality, methodology, clarity, and scientific contribution
- Ensure that feedback is specific and helpful to both authors and editors
- Support all critical observations with clear reasoning where necessary
Recommendation Section
At the end of the evaluation, reviewers should indicate an overall recommendation regarding the manuscript. This decision should reflect the overall quality of the work and its suitability for publication within the Journal.
Confidential Comments
Reviewers may be given the option to provide confidential remarks intended solely for the Editorial Board. These comments should not include feedback meant for the authors but may highlight concerns or considerations relevant to editorial decision-making.
Comments to Authors
Reviewers should provide constructive feedback directed to the authors, focusing on how the manuscript can be improved. This may include suggestions for clarification, methodological improvements, literature enhancement, or structural revisions.
Submission Guidelines
- Ensure all sections of the Review Form are completed before submission
- Review your comments for clarity, professionalism, and objectivity
- Submit the completed form within the specified review deadline
- Ensure no identifying information is included in your submission to preserve the double-blind review process
